|
|
Helpful Hints About Answering Questions
Terminology:
Team Member:
that's you!
Client:
the person who sent us a question.
Top 7 Tips for MathNerds Team Members
- Look over some Exemplary Answers from the archives.
- Give a hint, not a complete answer.
Hinting is a skill, and it is often more difficult to think of a good hint
than it is to give a complete solution! In our environment it is especially
difficult, since we don't know the people we are dealing with; we compensate
for this somewhat by asking the clients to give us their current school and
level of math background. Our automated system makes it easy to carry on a
dialog with the client through forms on the web site, so don't feel like
your hint has to be your last communication with the client. When in doubt,
give a smaller hint; the client will write back if he needs more help.
Usually our clients have already tried to work the problem and they are
writing to us because they are stuck. A hint is all it takes to get them
unstuck; you can assume they have already made an effort. A few clients
are lazy and write to us hoping we will do their homework for them
(we will not). Out of these a very small number will whine piteously if
we do not give them the complete answer; ignore the whining and give them
another hint. (Note: if the client is a parent we usually give a complete
answer, since they will do the teaching for us.)
Some good general-purpose hints you can use or adapt as appropriate:
- Suggest that they draw a picture or graph.
- Point out a special case or example that they can try first.
- Suggest a simpler version of the problem that they can do as practice
(for example, a problem in three dimensions may have a two-dimensional
analog that is easier).
Many questions that we receive are things you look up, not things you
figure out, and hinting usually won't work for these (for example: "Who
was Emmy Noether?" "What's the name of an 11-sided polygon?"). For these
questions we don't give hints, but we usually don't give the answer directly
either; we point the client to a Web resource where he can look up the answer.
Familiarize yourself with the contents of our Links page; the links here
were chosen specifically because they answer many of the questions that we
receive. Contrary to popular belief, all human knowledge is not on the Web
yet; you can also point the client to readily-available books such as
English dictionaries (surprisingly useful), encyclopedias, and almanacs.
- If you are not going to answer a question, put it on the General Queue.
Do not simply ignore a question that you are not going to answer;
please send it to the General Queue so that someone else can answer it.
Many of our Team Members scan the General Queue looking for interesting questions,
and most questions placed on the General Queue do get answered. Conversely you
yourself should check the General Queue for things you can answer. The General
Queue is not a "reject queue"; most of the questions are perfectly good questions,
but they got to the General Queue because the original assignee doesn't work
in that area, or got overloaded, or just got tired of explaining how to set up
a system of two linear equations in two variables.
Don't answer a question with a simple "I don't know"; let someone else answer
it. Once in a while we get research problems; in this case it is all right to
say "nobody knows" and then summarize or point them to whatever is known
about the problem.
- If the question has several parts, you don't have to answer them all.
Often a question contains several problems, all of which can be solved the same
way. For these, you might work out one of them as an example and tell the
client the others can be done similarly. Occasionally we receive a "laundry
list" of 5 or 10 unrelated questions; don't feel you have to answer all of
them, just do one or two. If the client still needs help with the others he
will ask again.
- Read the Archives.
You'll learn a lot about mathematics and how to explain it on the Web, and
about what kind of Web resources there are for mathematics. You'll also see
that many questions occur over and over again; you can refer to the Archives
instead of repeating an answer (but usually you should give a hint instead
of pointing them to a complete answer).
- Be Polite.
On the Internet, no one knows you are a nice guy. Always be polite and
courteous in your answers, no matter how exasperating the client is.
- Ignore the Garbage and Don't take the Bait.
Unfortunately, we occasionally get non-mathematical submissions.
These range from silly (or even obscene) statements such as "You
guys are really geeks!" to unanswerable questions such as "Can you
help me to understand differential equations for my test tomorrow?"
Please send these to the General Queue, or (if they they are completely frivolous)
use the Delete button to delete them. Do not respond to them.
If you answer them, then your answer is cataloged
in our archive. If you receive an obscene message, please forward it to Ted or
Valerio and we will assure that it is deleted from
the archive.
Top 5 FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions) for MathNerds Team Members
- I don't understand the question! What should I do?
This happens frequently. It happens not because the questions are so hard,
but because when the client wrote the question he left out part of it. It's
very common for us to receive a long description of the hypothesis, with no
indication of the question or desired conclusion. The opposite also occurs:
for example, the original problem said "Factor the following completely"
followed by a long list of polynomials, and the only part the client sent us was
x^2 - 5x + 6
(that's the whole question, "x^2 - 5x + 6"). If you think the question has
a missing ingredient, often you can guess what it is and answer anyway; if
you can't guess, write back to the client (using the regular response box)
asking for a clarification.
Tip: often clients write the question partly in the title and partly in the
body; in the above "x^2 - 5x + 6" example, the title might be "Factoring
Polynomials", which would really make it a complete question.
- I don't know the answer! What should I do?
Put the question in the General Queue; probably someone else knows the
answer and will answer it.
- I signed up for questions in Number Theory and Calculus; why do I get
questions about Topology?
Occasionally clients mis-classify their questions. If you get a question
in an area you don't work in, put in on the General Queue.
- I made a mistake in my answer! What do I do?
You can't call back the answer, because it's already been mailed to the
client, but you can add to it. Just go to the same Web address you used
originally; you'll see an additional empty text box, and
you can add your correction and submit it. In case you don't have the
original Web address, try to look up the question in the Archives.
You can use the "View My Answers" action on the Team Member Main page to
view just your answers. Find the desired question and click it.
In the address display of your browser you should see something ending with
"?index=nnnnn" where nnnnn is your question number. Then go back to Team Member
Main and enter nnnnn in the Answer It section of the Quick View/Answer section.
- Should I sign my answers? Looking the archives I see that some people
do and some don't.
That's up to you. We recommend that you do sign them, because clients are
happier when they feel they are dealing with a human and not a faceless
corporate monolith. If you publish your e-mail address on the About page
then you should sign your answers too, otherwise the clients won't know
who you are!
|